Online marketing can be handled in-house or handed to an outside provider. There are also models with a fixed monthly price. I know agency work from my years with Schleier IT. When choosing a model, I would look less at the label and more at the work that comes up regularly.
An agency thinks in projects
A classic agency sells projects and hours. For a relaunch or a big campaign with a clear start and finish, that is the right format. You get a quote, a team for a set period and a result. It gets difficult in the day-to-day work that follows. Every small change needs a new quote or lands on the hourly invoice, and at some point you stop asking because last month's bill still annoys you. That is how exactly the small improvements that make the difference in marketing over months get left undone. I saw this pattern often enough from the agency side, and it was rarely down to bad intentions.
One in-house hire can't do everything
Hire internally and you get someone who knows your product and your customers better than any outside provider. That is worth a lot, and I mean that. Then the job ad asks one single person for Google Ads, SEO, graphics, copywriting, tracking and social media. This person does not exist. In practice they are good at two of those disciplines and administer the rest. Add vacations, sick days and the day they hand in their notice and take their knowledge with them. A hire of your own pays off when marketing is core to your business and there is enough work for a specialist. For the breadth you will still need outside help.
What a fixed monthly price changes
With a fixed monthly price, you know in January what marketing will cost in June. The small change that would have needed a quote from an agency simply goes on the list. That only works if the contract says what the price includes, meaning which services, how many tasks at the same time and how quickly someone responds. A flat fee without those details is a bet, and usually the client loses it.
The model fits well when similar work comes up month after month, such as maintaining ads, adjusting pages and writing reports. Then a fixed meeting pays off, where you set the order of tasks together and look at the previous month's results. Without that meeting, the provider works through whatever was shouted loudest.
When a subscription doesn't fit
A subscription has a rhythm and works through one thing after another. If you need a complete relaunch in six weeks with ten people working on it at once, a project agency is the right place. If your demand swings a lot, you pay for idle time in the quiet months. A subscription also needs someone on your side who sets goals and approves results. Without that person, finished work piles up at your door while you keep paying. In my experience this is where subscriptions fail most often, and when they do, the cause sits with the client.
Read the fine print, too. The ad budget for Google or Meta is almost never included in the monthly price. It comes on top. Ask how many tasks run in parallel and how quickly one gets done, because “unlimited” usually means “one after another.” Clarify the notice period. And ask who owns the accounts. Ad accounts, analytics and the website have to be in your company's name, whichever model you choose. If you have to ask for access to your own data when you part ways, you were not paying attention when you signed.
Four questions before you decide
First, how even is your demand across the year? A steady stream of small and medium-sized tasks points to a subscription, and one big chunk points to an agency. Second, how many disciplines do you need in a normal month? From three upward, a single hire gets stretched thin. Third, who on your side sets goals and approves results, and does that person actually have time for it? Fourth, how much is it worth to you that someone sits in-house every day and knows your product inside out? In my experience a mix is often the best answer, with one person in-house who knows the direction and a subscription or an agency doing the execution.
